Asphalt Shingle vs Metal Roofing: Which is Better for Your Home?

When deciding on a new roof you may be looking at the pros and cons of asphalt shingle roofing vs steel roofing for your home. Here’s a quick look at the advantages and disadvantages of the two materials.

If you have any questions, we at Artisan Roofing Inc. serve Moncton NB and surrounding areas, including Riverview, Dieppe, Salisbury and more! We would be happy to answer any questions or help you pick the right roof for your needs.

Contact us at

Now lets get to the comparison!

Asphalt Shingle Roofing


In most areas, the most popular roofing material is usually asphalt shingle roofing. Because it is usually a cost-effective option and has a traditional look, it’s the roofing material that most homeowners opt for.

What are the benefits of asphalt shingle roofing?

When looking around most neighbourhoods, you’ll likely notice that most of them have asphalt shingles. If you’re looking for something more traditional that will blend in with the other homes in your neighborhood then this will be your best bet.

Asphalt shingle roofing is also affordable and less labor-intensive, which helps if you’re on a tight budget. If you’re looking to install roofing yourself, you’re going to want to take a look at asphalt shingles as well because it’s the easiest to work with.

Also we offer a whopping 50 YEAR WARRANTY with our premium asphalt shingles. Plus for those that are not aware, the warranty is NOT on the product but rather carried by the INSTALLER. So if you use a “discount” roofer, they will not be covered to validate the warranty.

What are the downsides to asphalt shingle roofing?

Of course, there are some cons to asphalt shingles when you’re comparing them to metal roofing. Some of the disadvantages are that they tend to absorb heat in the summertime and when replaced they generally end up in landfills because they aren’t recyclable and contain toxic chemicals.

When compared to metal, asphalt shingles are less durable, can be subject to hail damage and tend to weigh more. They’re also more susceptible to mildew and mold.


Metal Roofing


Metal roofing is rarely seen in suburban or urban areas and is more popular in agricultural settings. However, it does come in a variety of colors and styles that you can select to match the rest of your home.

Types of Metal Roofing

When considering metal roofing, you need to know that there are many different types. The different types vary in cost, durability, appearance and more. If you’re in the Moncton NB and surrounding areas, including Riverview, Dieppe, Salisbury we’d be happy to go over the options with you.

The types of metal roofing are:

  • Tin
  • Steel
  • Aluminum
  • Copper
  • Zinc
  • Seam Standing Metal


What are the benefits of metal roofing?

Metal roofing is a wonderful option when you’re looking for variety and longevity. It’s also very durable and resistant to the elements if you live in an area where that is important. In addition, it’s usually more energy-efficient and because of all of this, it’s better for resale value if you plan to sell your home in the future.

One huge advantage of metal roofing is that it’s recyclable and doesn’t have to end up in a landfill like asphalt roofing with it’s toxic chemicals. In addition, it’s fire-resistant, has longer warranties, requires little maintenance, and is generally lighter than asphalt shingles.


What are the downsides to metal roofing?

Because they’re more difficult to install they’re not a good choice for anyone wanting to DIY their roof. Due to the labor required to install and the cost of the materials, they tend to cost more which is a huge deciding factor for most people. Metal roofing can also be noisy without proper installation, can look more agricultural and less aesthetically appealing in most neighbourhoods, and can be more difficult to repair.

The comparison above should help you make a decision for your own roof. In the end, it all depends on your budget and your needs. Give us a call and we’d be happy to go over any options you want to consider.